Go to Table of Contents

## Dissonance handling

As with all style 'rules' in Counterpointer, each of these can be turned on or off as needed to produce the desired style. They are available in the Set Style window when doing Free Counterpoint.

A pitch is 'dissonant' if it forms an unstable interval with other pitches. Stable or consonant intervals are the octave, fifth, thirds and sixths. Unstable or dissonant intervals are the others: seconds, sevenths, and particularly the augmented 4th and diminished 5th. Any augmented or diminished interval will also be considered dissonant in part-writing, though some of these (e.g. the diminished fourth) actually sound, on a piano, the same pitches as consonant intervals. The octave and the fifth are known as "perfect consonances" and the thirds and sixths are "imperfect consonances."

Treat the 3rd and 6th as dissonant (could be used for a very early polyphonic style). This option is provided just for the fun of it. Early music theorists thought in terms of scales tuned by a series of perfect fifths, in which the thirds and sixths sounded harsh, and consequently did not regard these intervals as perfect enough for points of rest, but merely something to be passed through on the way to a perfect consonance. If you select this option thirds and sixths will join the ranks of dissonances, and will require the kind of approach and departure expected of dissonances.

Treat the P 4th with bass as dissonant. This option is normally set, but could be turned off to create an archaic style. The perfect fourth is unique among the intervals in that it is treated sometimes as a dissonance and sometimes as a consonance. When formed with the bass it is normally considered dissonant. There is a special case called the "consonant fourth," about which you'll see more below.

Treat the Aug 4 and Dim 5 as consonant if not involving bass. In three or more parts it may be acceptable to treat these dissonances more freely in the upper voices. This exception accounts for the tradition in tonal music of writing the diminished triad in first inversion. If you want to treat these intervals as consonant even in two parts if they imply a diminished triad or dominant seventh chord, use the option to allow free use of "essential" dissonances (bottom of this page). That would be appropriate only in tonal counterpoint.

The minor and diminished seventh of a chord will be considered essential. All exceptions for essential dissonances so far apply just to the diminished fifth or augmented fourth formed in the diminished triad. With this option that freedom is extended to chords that use a minor seventh (such as the dominant seventh chord and the minor seventh chord) or a diminished seventh. Examples:

Allow essential tones to dissonate freely with other essential tones. Dissonances lying outside the prevailing harmony will still require appropriate handling.

Permit no dissonance (as in first species exercises). This really is useful only in the case of First Species exercises.

Allow essential dissonances.

No leap to dissonance. If checked, a leap to dissonance will be allowed only if the instance meets one of the following exceptions.

Allow unaccented leap to anticipation. An anticipation is an unaccented (metrically weak) note that while dissonant itself anticipates a following accented consonance on the same pitch. Usually it is approached by a downward second, but if you check this box a leap will be permitted:

Allow if leap is between essential tones. That is, allow if both notes are part of the sounding harmony. That would include chords such as the diminished triad and the dominant seventh chord, which contain dissonant intervals. Another way to allow this is to check the box at the bottom of this window that permits essential tones to freely dissonate with other essential tones. But that allows more leeway than this exception by itself.

Allow leap to dissonance in cambiata. The cambiata is a figure that usually begins with a downward second to an unaccented note, then a downward third followed by an upward second to another unaccented note, so that it ends a third away from its beginning. Both the second and third notes can be dissonant.

Leap in cambiata must be downward. The normal cambiata is formed with a downward leap, but if this box is not checked the inverted cambiata will also be acceptable.

Allow appoggiatura. The appoggiatura typically is formed by an upward leap to an accented dissonance, followed by a downward stepwise resolution. This is one of the most satisfying of dissonances in tonal counterpoint, but is not found in the Palestrina style.

Allow inverted appoggiatura. The inverted appoggiatura deservedly does not get much respect. If allowed, the leap would be downward, followed by an upward step:

Allow unaccented appoggiatura. This also is an unusual device, though less so than the inverted appoggiatura:

Allow leap by the moving voice in a suspension (with correct resolution of held voice). When dissonance is considered by interval rather than by chord, both notes of the dissonant interval are of course equally dissonant. So a suspension whose moving voice leaps to the downbeat could be seen as an instance of a leap to dissonance. Check this box if you want the typical suspension to be available for use in modal counterpoint. On the other hand, if you are allowing free treatment of essential dissonances (dissonant tones that are part of the prevailing chord) then this exception is not required as long as the harmony is clear.

No simultaneous dissonance (do not begin two dissonant notes simultaneously, though they can overlap). This rule is necessary for enforcing Fourth Species counterpoint principles. Jeppeson observes (p. 153) that it derives from the principle that in First Species (note against note) there can be no dissonance. Strictly speaking, there are some exceptions for rapid notes.

No accented dissonances (below exceptions can include those listed above for the appoggiatura). By accented we mean "metrically accented" (see Fundamental Principles).

Allow suspension. Suspension is the figure in which an unaccented consonant note (the 'preparation') is sustained onto a downbeat at which it becomes dissonant in context and then resolves by step, normally downward. This is a place for more exceptional treatment of the fourth: the fourth can be used as a consonant preparation in a suspension if the bass of the fourth remains (letting that fourth resolve to a third over the same bass). See Jeppeson, p. 193 ff. and Kitson p. 117.

Require preparation to be equal to or longer than dissonance. That is, do not tie a shorter value to a longer one.

Allow delayed resolution. Delayed or ornamental resolution of a suspension means that one or possibly more relatively brief notes intervene between the dissonance and its normal downward resolution by step. Counterpointer will be able to understand one note of delay if this option is checked.

Allow 'consonant fourth' preparation. Though the fourth formed with the bass is normally considered dissonant, Palestrina and his contemporaries accepted this very mild dissonance as preparation for a suspension in cases where the bass continues onto the following downbeat and the fourth is approached by step. Not only can the fourth serve as its own preparation in this case, it can also resolve a previous dissonance. This is discussed in Jeppeson(p. 193). who provides an example from Palestrina and also supplies an example (p. 189) in which the consonant fourth resolves a dissonance. Kitson (p. 117) mentions that Cherubini approved the consonant fourth but required that it be prepared by a concord (i.e. he did not allow it to serve as resolution of a dissonance). Counterpointer goes with Jeppeson on this one.

The asterisk marks the consonant fourth in this example. Note that the bass repeats and the fourth is approached by step, and that it also serves to resolve the previous seventh formed with the E in the middle voice.

Require preparation to be unaccented. The preparation note is the unaccented consonant beginning of the tone that becomes dissonant on the following metric accent. As seen above, this is the normal suspension.

Allow "repeated note" suspension. This is a suspension that is, so to speak, not suspended. The preparation and dissonance are the same pitch but are not tied. This gives more prominence to the dissonance; it is not consistent with the Palestrina style.

Avoid using note of resolution in dissonant sonority. At the moment of dissonance the pitch class of the resolution should not be already present somewhere else in the sonority. In the following example the note of resolution is C, already present in the middle voice.

Avoid upward resolution. Upward resolution of a suspension is not typical of the Palestrina style.

Avoid continued sixth in a 4-3 suspension (continued 6th above lower tone). This is perhaps less technical than it sounds: in modern harmonic terms it means that if you continue a sixth above the root in a 4-3 suspension you're writing a 2nd inversion triad that moves to the harmony a third above its root - not a strong harmonic movement (e.g. I 6/4 to iii6). In the Palestrina style the sixth would move to a fifth, making in modern terms a strong I 6/4 to V.

Allow accented passing or neighbor tones. Also known as "auxiliary tones" and "embellishments," these are tones usually found in unaccented positions. A passing tone passes stepwise through a dissonance, either ascending or descending. A neighboring tone also moves stepwise but returns to the note with which it began.

Allowed accented dissonances should resolve to imperfect consonances (3rds or 6ths). This rule is consistent with 16th century practice: a resolution to a 3rd or 6th is thought to heighten the effect of resolution.

Allow 9-8.

Allow 2-1.

Allow 4-5. Jeppeson (p.131) allows no exceptions to the above rule, but Fux (Mann, p.57 ff.) does mention using the 9-8, 2-1, and 4-5 as long as they are prepared in such a way as to avoid parallels:

Allowed accented dissonances must be at least one beat in value. In the Palestrina style accented dissonances are not found on quick notes.

Can be less if on a weak beat (e.g. beat 2 or 4 in 4/4 or beat 2 in 2/2). Allowing for other styles - but this might seem confusing: if the dissonance is on a weak beat how can it be accented? The answer is that it could still be accented in relation to the following note. In a pair of eighth notes on the fourth beat, the first eighth is accented with respect to the second one.

The upper tone of an accented 7th and lower tone of an accented 2nd should resolve downward. That is, not only should an accented seventh move to a sixth, but it should do so by letting the upper tone move down rather than by moving the lower tone up. The lower tone of the second is of course the inverted seventh and would do the same thing.

Allow pedal tone dissonance (other notes can freely dissonate with the pedal once it has begun). A pedal will be defined as a note that lasts (or repeats) through more than six pitch changes in other voices. Really it would be better to define it as a tone that is held through two or more changes of harmony, but for technical reasons we'll make this arbitrary definition. A note meeting that description will, if this option is set, be ignored when considering dissonance handling.

Pedal must be tonic or dominant. The pedal is most often used on one of the two primary tones of the key, particularly the dominant.

Resolve dissonance immediately by step. By 'immediately' we mean that the note following the dissonance must be consonant.

Allow escape tone. The escape tone is an unaccented dissonance that is approached by step and left by downward leap:

Require escape to be downward.

Allow cambiata. The classic 4-tone cambiata may violate both the leap from dissonance rule and the leap to dissonance rule (see example above).

Allow double auxiliary. The double auxiliary looks like a cambiata but returns to the pitch on which it began. This is a device not known in the Palestrina style (see Piston, p.57).

Allow indirect resolution of fourth. This would not be appropriate in the Palestrina style, but may be seen in tonal counterpoint, especially if instrumental. The pitch of resolution of the fourth (e in this case) appears in the following sonority, but not in the same voice or octave:

Allow intervening essential tones before resolution. This allows a stepwise resolution to be delayed by notes that are part of the prevailing harmony. The F in this example resolves to E, but only after an intervening D that is part of the G7 chord:

Essential dissonance can serve as resolution. If you are considering dissonance in harmonic terms then this option allows a dissonance to be resolved by another dissonance if the second one is part of a chord. A chain of seventh chords would be an example: in the below an essential B-F dissonance moves to an essential Bb-E, then to A-Eb, and finally to a consonant Bb triad.

Allow 2 successive dissonances if quick, stepwise, in the same direction, and the first is unaccented. By 'quick' we mean less than a beat in value:

Allow 2 successive dissonances if they are quick and stepwise. This allows the first to be in an accented position.

Allow successive dissonance if the second tone is an anticipation. Example:

Avoid upper auxillary tones (upper neighbor tones).

Allow if note of return is longer.

Avoid unaccented dissonance resolved by movement of a different voice. For example, a suspension is prepared by a consonance. If you prepare a suspension with a dissonance that then resolves to a consonance when the other dissonant voice moves, that would violate this rule.

Go to Table of Contents

© 2020 Ars Nova Software, LLC